Stage Door Review

Cottagers and Indians

Wednesday, February 6, 2019


by Drew Hayden Taylor, directed by Melody A. Johnson

Tarragon Theatre, Tarragon Theatre, Toronto

February 6-24, 2019

Drew Hayden Taylor’s Cottagers and Indians, now receiving its world premiere at the Tarragon Theatre, is surprisingly light, unchallenging entertainment.

The play is based on current disputes over harvesting wild rice on Pigeon, Chemong and Buckhorn Lakes. Though well acted, Taylor’s play portrays the dispute as a comedy by making the Cottager a caricatured bigot and giving the sample Indian all the funny lines.  

Under Patti Shaughnessy’s direction, the affable Arthur Copper (Herbie Barnes), an Anishinaabe from the area, remains on the watery half of Robin Fisher’s lakeside set while his opponent, the brittle Maureen Poole (Tracey Hoyt), an upper middle-class woman from North York, remains on her half, a cottage deck.

Poole’s dispute with Copper is that his wild rice plants fill the lake and make swimming or boating impossible while also lowering her property’s value. Copper’s view is that he is simply reviving a practice of his ancestors that provides his people with a healthier diet.  

Poole and Copper alternate monologues as they explain the history of their conflict. Humour arises in three ways. One is from Copper’s satire of white city folk who want to get back to nature to “centre themselves,” if only for a few weekends per year, while he lives with nature every day.

Another is from Taylor’s portrait of Poole as a fool who insists that she is not prejudiced (she’s seen Dances With Wolves!) when, in fact, her prejudice is so ingrained she can’t see it.

Best, though, is the humour that comes breaking theatrical convention by allowing each character to hear and comment on the other’s monologues though they are spoken directly to the audience.

Theatre-goers who’ve chosen to see a show with this title know what the right side of this dispute is within the first 10 minutes. So it’s unnecessary for Taylor to skew the fight by making Poole into the comic caricature of a privileged white woman to contrast with the fully rounded character of an Indigenous man.

Since the outcome of the dispute is not in doubt, there is no real tension. We leave likely thinking the same as when we entered: that white privilege and sentimentality are no match for First Nations’ practicality and the preservation of ancient tradition.  

Christopher Hoile

Note: This review appeared in NOW Magazine on February 23, 2018. For its second run Billy Merasty and Carmen Grant play the two roles and Melody A. Johnson has replaced Patti Shaughnessy as director.

Photo: Herbie Barnes and Tracey Hoyt. © 2018 Cylla von Tiedemann

For tickets, visit