✭✭✭✭✭

by Clare Barron, directed by Diana Bentley

Coal Mine Theatre & Outside the March with Rock Bottom Movement, Coal Mine Theatre, 2076 Danforth Avenue, Toronto

April 16–May 10, 2026

Amina: “You hesitate, you’re dead”

Dance Nation is an exciting show unlike any other. Coal Mine Theatre’s coproduction with Outside the March and Rock Bottom Movement has turned a play about dance competitions for young teens into an unforgettable immersive experience. We follow a team from Liverpool, Ohio, as a team and as individuals, from their first success through preparations for a major competition to the competition and after. The young teens are all played by early to late middle-aged actors. It is worth the price of admission just to see how these adults capture with wonderful accuracy the quirks and habits of young people without ever trying to sweeten their personalities. It is a delight simply to see favourite actors whom you’ve never seen dance before dance with such aplomb.

There are innumerable sports movies and plays out there about how a ragtag team, despite setbacks, finally achieves glory. American playwright Clare Barron is not interested in reproducing that clichéd scenario. Instead, she focusses on how being part of a group under pressure influences the development of 13-year-olds poised at that confusing time between childhood and adulthood.

The play begins with a dance performed by the team in competition involving the seven girls dressed as sailors and the lone boy costumed as a lobster, the action consisting of the former attempting to catch the latter. The dance ends with an ill omen. One dancer, Vanessa, breaks her leg and cries for help, but all the team members not knowing what to do scream and flee. Barron thus sets up a tension between the individual and group that she pursues in more detail throughout the play.

After this accident the action consists of speeches to the team from its severe teacher Pat, who sometimes stirs up unbridled enthusiasm, sometimes mercilessly upbraids them. Interspersed with depictions of dance practice and conversations between two people or along the whole group, Barron places monologues of the seven team members as their older selves looking back on their time as 13-year-olds.

From this mix of action and introspection a storyline gradually emerges. Dance Teacher Pat, as he is known, has decided that theme of the dance number that the team will take to its next competitions will be “Gandhi” (no problem that the dancers don’t know who he was). The desire for the title role pits team members against each other, but when they hear that the number will also include a character known as “The Spirit of Gandhi” who has a more active role, everyone assumes Pat will give it to Amina, the “star” of the team.

Contrary to expectations, Pat gives the role to the team’s second-best dancer, Zuzu. He does so to give her a chance and knows that any agents in the audience will spot Amina’s talent without her having to be in main role. For this point on the play concerns the tension between Amina and Zuzu and Amina and the group. We soon notice that being known as the “star” of the team means being left out of any group discussions. Everyone admires how beautifully Amina dances but that admiration doesn’t translate into friendship.

Director Diana Bentley and Movement Director Alyssa Martin have assembled an unbeatable cast. In her Notes on Casting, Barron states not only that the cast should in no way look like 13-year-olds, but that it is “better if the actors possess no real dance talent”. That being so, the Coal Mine cast do a fantastic job acting without being cute (“Cuteness is death”, according to Barron) and performing extended dance numbers. The dance numbers are not pauses in the action but continuations by other means of the tensions that develop in the dialogue. It is perfectly appropriate and, indeed, realistic if the members of the team do not dance in perfect synch. What is most important is that we see they are all trying their best.

Beck Lloyd as Amina and Annie Luján as Zuzu represent two members of the team whose experience in dance competitions takes them in opposite directions. Lloyd exudes a steely, refined strength none of the others possess. She moves and dances so gracefully it’s hard to think she has no previous experience. At the same time, Lloyd conveys the strain Amina feels being regarded as separate with only Dance Teacher Pat to confide in.

Annie Luján presents Zuzu in all that character’s confusion both about dance and about life in general. Zuzu says she has wanted to be a dancer since the age of two, but the fact that she has such a pushy mother makes us wonder whether her dream and her mother’s ambition for her have prevented her from knowing herself and thinking about what else she might want to do. Vanessa’s accident at the start of the play reminds all the team that their career as a dancer could end in just a moment. Luján makes us understand completely why Zuzu rejects friendship with Amina, since Amina’s unconscious perfection only reminds Zuzu of a height she can never reach.

The rest of the team all have moments to shine. As Ashlee, Amy Keating has a great monologue of self-praise projecting a fierceness in her imagination that she dare not reveal in public. As Sofia, Jean Yoon gives us a girl on the verge of womanhood with a comically insatiable curiosity about sex. As Connie, Zorana Sadiq presents us with a young girl who is fully content to be young. In an insightful scene, Barron has Sofia on one side of the stage contemplating how to cope with her first period, while Connie on the other side is happily playing with her “lucky” horse and all the horse’s other horse friends.

Two dancers not fully integrated into the team are Maeve and Luke. Katherine Cullen’s Maeve has been in the team longer than anyone else, yet Cullen shows us that Maeve is the least talented and least committed. Cullen suggests that being part of the team is the only positive aspect of her life. Oliver Dennis is quite endearing as Luke. Dennis fully captures the nature of a boy who, as is common at that age, is not quite as bright as the girls. He thinks he is in love with Zuzu, even though she is not in love with him. Luke tells us in his monologue that his favourite thing is falling asleep while his mother is talking to him.

Salvatore Antonio is suitably imperious as Dance Teacher Pat. Antonio delivers Pat’s speeches about living up to the great teams of the past from Liverpool, Ohio, with a gravitas that is comic considering its context. Antonio is especially good in revealing Pat’s integrity when he argues with Zuzu’s Mom who believes that there is no such thing as talent.

Amy Matysio, among several roles, plays that Mom with livid intensity, reflecting all the parents out there who think their children must constantly be praised whether the children deserve it or not. In complete contrast, she also plays Luke’s kind mother who is simply happy is Luke is happy.

This production is different from all other productions in Coal Mine Theatre’s history in that it uses both floors of the building it occupies at 2076 Danforth. The upstairs, known as The Vault, serves as the dance rehearsal hall. The audience is seated on either side of the long playing area whose entire length Bentley and Martin have used for dramatic scenes and dance. After intermission, the audience is led downstairs to the theatre where all previous Coal Mine shows at this address have been staged.

Nick Blais has given this a look unlike any it has had before. There is a runway leading to a circular performing area surrounded by seating. Blais has hung leafy vines from the ceiling giving the auditorium the look of the Winter Garden Theatre. Just as the team from Liverpool, Ohio, travels to a new venue to perform, so we, the audience, travel to the new venue to see their performance.

I have seen photos of conventional productions of Dance Nation and can say that we are very lucky that Coal Mine Theatre and Outside the March with Rock Bottom Movement have combined to make Barron’s play such an involving, immersive experience. The characters in the play undertake a memorable journey, and so do we. Coal Mine concludes its season with yet another stunner of a production not to be missed.

Christopher Hoile

Photos: Jean Yoon as Sofia, Katherine Cullen as Maeve, Amy Keating as Ashlee, Beck Lloyd as Amina, Zorana Sadiq as Connie, Annie Luján as Zuzu and Oliver Dennis as Luke; Annie Luján as Zuzu; Jean Yoon as Sofia (foreground) with Zorana Sadiq as Connie and Katherine Cullen as Maeve (background); Beck Lloyd as Amina. © 2026 Elana Emer.

For tickets visit: www.coalminetheatre.com.