Niagara-on-the-Lake: Councillors approve rebuilding the Royal George Theatre
Sunday, October 19, 2025
The show will go on for Shaw Festival’s $50-million Royal George Theatre rebuilding project.
In a reversal that took a circuitous route, elected officials during Tuesday’s town council meeting voted 6-3 to support Shaw Festival’s application for official plan and zoning bylaw amendments to build the estimated 4,920-square-metre building on Queen Street.
“We are happy to see council’s decision to let us move ahead and respect the town’s commitment to a thorough process regarding the future of our Royal George Theatre project,” Shaw Festival executive director Tim Jennings said in a statement.
“With the approval of the staff report and plan amendments, we now look forward to working with town staff on the next steps.”
During the Nov. 11 committee of the whole meeting, councillors voted against the planning amendments, but approved a motion directing town staff to discuss with Shaw Festival officials a variety of issues, including allowing the public to use washrooms in the new theatre, accessible parking, reducing the size of the design and retaining trees at the rear of the property.
“I’ve had a terrible couple of days,” said Coun. Gary Burroughs, one of the councillors who initially voted against the project’s application.
Burroughs said he was “supportive” of the Shaw Festival.
“I approve what they are suggesting.”
Outgoing community services director Kirsten McCauley said staff met with Shaw officials soon after the Nov. 11 meeting was finished to discuss the many issues councillors raised.
“We have initiated this discussion,” said McCauley. “(Shaw officials) have demonstrated a revised site plan.”
She also confirmed to councillors that Shaw officials would be willing to seek an operating agreement outside of the zoning approval with the town to gain public access to the washrooms inside the new theatre.
A five-page letter on Nov. 16, signed by Jennings, artistic director Tim Carroll and associate artistic director Kimberley Rampersad, stated Shaw officials were willing to discuss an operating agreement with the town to allow the public to use the proposed 13 designated main-floor washrooms in the new theatre, provide cash-in-lieu for a parking spot and establish five accessible parking spaces.
But Shaw officials were emphatic that they could not reduce the scope of the theatre design.
The letter said if councillors rejected the application, it would mean “the abandonment of the project by the Shaw and the likely sale of the conjoined property by the board.”
The letter also said further delays to the project would cost Shaw more than $200,000 a month, and the theatre would not be completed for the fall 2028 season.
Still, councillors on Tuesday voted to support the committee of the whole’s motion that opposed endorsing the planning amendments, but to continue discussions with Shaw officials in a 5-4 vote, which would at least delay the project.
But after a 10-minute break in the meeting announced by Lord Mayor Gary Zalepa, councillors returned and voted 6-3 to rescind the original motion. Couns. Tim Balasiuk and Burroughs changed their minds.
Councillors then approved the planning amendments in a 6-3 vote for the project at 178-188 Victoria St. and 79-83 Queen St., which included updates for accessible parking onsite. The motion also directed staff to accept the cash-in-lieu for the one parking spot, to co-operate with Shaw officials to prepare an operating agreement that will allow the public to use the restrooms in the new theatre and to settle any outstanding issues.
Couns. Sandra O’Connor, Andrew Niven and Maria Mavridis opposed the motion.
O’Connor and Niven repeated their arguments that they couldn’t support such a large project downtown.
“My main concern is the mass and size,” said O’Connor. “It has not been adequately addressed. It will set a precedent” for the neighbourhood.
O’Connor said it was also “unclear” whether the heritage committee’s suggestions will be incorporated into the project.
During the Nov. 5 heritage committee meeting, members approved a commemoration plan for the new project that will highlight the history and heritage of the Royal George Theatre and the surrounding neighbourhood.
Council has already approved demolition of the Royal George buildings along Victoria Street for the project, but the heritage committee still must approve the demolition of the current Royal George Theatre.
By Kevin Werner for www.niagarathisweek.com
Illustration: Artist’s rendering of the new Royal George Theatre.